Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe: Homemade Summer Treat

Craving a frozen treat that’s rich, creamy, and has that irresistible caramelized crunch? This Biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe brings together the best of two worlds: spiced cookie butter and velvety vanilla ice cream. Perfect for backyard barbecues, summer afternoons, or a quiet indulgence, it’s a no-churn, no-fuss dessert that’s impossible to resist. We’ll walk through the story behind this treat, the ingredients and process, and how to tweak it for different variations. Whether you’re curious about the Biscoff flavor or how to make a sandwich from scratch, this recipe covers everything you need to know.

Homemade Magic with Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwiches

A Farmhouse Moment That Sparked a Frozen Favorite

Out here on the farm, summer days get long and golden. I remember the first time I made these Biscoff ice cream sandwiches it was late July, and we had a house full of cousins visiting. The kitchen was full of chatter, and someone had brought a jar of cookie butter. That jar didn’t last long. We were spreading it on everything, but the true magic happened when I sandwiched it between two soft cookies and tucked in a scoop of homemade vanilla ice cream.

That first bite? Buttery, cool, with a warm whisper of spice. It reminded me of cinnamon toast from childhood breakfasts only colder and creamier. Ever since, this Biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe has been a staple in our summer rotation. The best part is how simple it is to make, and it’s an absolute hit with guests. You can whip up a big batch and keep them in the freezer for an easy treat after dinner or a reward after chores.

And while the countryside sun warms the tomatoes in the garden, I’m often in the farmhouse kitchen, blending familiar flavors into something just a little unexpected. These ice cream sandwiches are exactly that classic, with a twist.

Want to know what’s in the middle of an ice cream sandwich? It’s typically ice cream (vanilla is classic), but with these, you’re getting cookie butter swirled right in, making each bite better than the last. You can even use homemade ice cream, just like I do in my ice cream crumble cookie that balances cool creaminess with crisp, buttery bits. For even more texture, try pairing it with soft summer cookies or spiced cookie layers from the farm kitchen.

The Power of Biscoff: Why We Love It

Biscoff, if you haven’t had it yet, is that deeply rich, spiced, caramel flavor that tastes like holiday cookies in a jar. Technically, it’s made from “speculoos” cookies Belgian spiced shortbread with a crunch that lingers. But it’s not just the flavor it’s the nostalgia. There’s a reason Biscoff pairs so well with ice cream. It balances the cold sweetness with warmth and crunch, giving every bite a layered experience.

In the next section, I’ll walk you through exactly how to make your own Biscoff ice cream from scratch no machine needed and how to get that signature creamy swirl that makes this recipe a standout. We’ll also answer: What are the ingredients in Biscoff cream? and Can you buy ice cream sandwich wafers?

How to Make a Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe from Scratch

Easy Homemade Biscoff Ice Cream: No-Churn Method

Let’s start with the heart of any good biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe the ice cream. The great news? You don’t need an ice cream maker. All you need is heavy cream, sweetened condensed milk, and a generous swirl of cookie butter. Start by whipping the cream until soft peaks form. In a separate bowl, combine the condensed milk with warmed Biscoff spread until smooth. Fold the whipped cream into the Biscoff mixture gently, keeping that airy texture.

Want to take it up a notch? Stir in crushed Lotus Biscoff cookies for texture. Freeze this mixture in a loaf pan for at least 6 hours. What makes the Biscoff flavor so unique is its blend of caramelized sugar, cinnamon, and spice a profile that transforms even simple ice cream into something unforgettable. You’ll find a similar warming balance in our sweet potato patty recipe, which also leans into cozy, seasonal flavors from the garden.

For those wondering what are the ingredients in Biscoff cream?, they include crushed Biscoff cookies, sugar, oil, and spices giving it that signature smooth texture and deeply spiced finish. This combo pairs beautifully with cold dairy and acts as a bridge between cookie and cream.

Building the Sandwich: Cookie Layers That Hold It All Together

Now that your ice cream’s ready, it’s time to craft the sandwich. While you can definitely buy ice cream sandwich wafers, I prefer baking soft Biscoff-spiced cookies using ingredients like brown sugar, butter, and a little cinnamon. They stay chewy even when frozen. You could also go with classic graham crackers or even my roasted shallot and garlic bread dough variation for a savory-sweet twist that still feels cozy and homemade.

Scoop the Biscoff ice cream onto one cookie, press another on top, and freeze again briefly so they set. Just like that, your biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe is ready to enjoy or stash for later.

Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe Variations & Seasonal Twists

Creative Takes on the Classic Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

One of the reasons I love this biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe is how adaptable it is. Once you’ve made the base no-churn Biscoff ice cream and soft cookie layers you can switch things up depending on what’s in your pantry or what’s growing outside. Want to add some tartness? A swirl of strawberry jam or roasted raspberries adds a fruity contrast that pairs beautifully with the caramel notes of Biscoff. You can even roll the sides of the sandwich in chopped toasted pecans or white chocolate chips for extra crunch.

When peaches are in season, I like to fold in diced orchard-fresh fruit right into the ice cream base. It’s a refreshing contrast that plays well with the cookie butter’s richness especially when served alongside something bright like our matcha chia seed lemonade. You can also try mini versions using bite-sized cookies for a kid-friendly treat that’s freezer-ready and portion-controlled.

Let’s not forget the texture. If you’re craving that satisfying bite from an old-school sandwich, try sandwiching the ice cream between homemade blondie bars or chewy molasses cookies for a spiced finish. You could even serve it alongside something savory like our golden onion and herb dip for a backyard gathering that balances sweet and savory. These options make this biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe a true seasonal favorite, no matter the time of year.

Pairings and Presentation: Farmhouse Style

Presentation matters, especially when you’ve put love into a dish. I like wrapping each sandwich in wax paper and tying it with twine it gives off that rustic, hand-crafted charm that mirrors our farm kitchen vibe. Serve them on a vintage enamel tray or tucked into a picnic basket beside a jug of iced tea and a plate of cheesy mushroom garlic toast for a full farm-style spread that balances sweet with savory.

With these small touches, the biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe feels less like dessert and more like a memory in the making.

Print

Final Tips for the Best Biscoff Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

What’s Inside and Why It Works So Well

If you’ve ever wondered what is in the middle of an ice cream sandwich?, it’s typically a scoop of creamy vanilla or chocolate nestled between two soft cookies or thin wafers. In this biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe, however, that middle is anything but basic. It’s a dreamy swirl of Biscoff cookie butter folded into no-churn vanilla cream, creating a layer that’s rich, spiced, and indulgent. You get the perfect contrast cool and creamy inside, chewy and caramelized outside.

As for what is the pink, white, and brown ice cream called? That’s Neapolitan! While it’s not used here, it’s another great idea for flavor layering if you’re customizing your biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe. You could even do a Neapolitan-style version using strawberry puree, vanilla, and cookie butter swirls.

For cookie layers, many ask: Can you buy ice cream sandwich wafers? Absolutely you can find them in baking aisles or online. But for something more homey, try making your own. I often use the dough from my ice cream crumble cookie recipe or even sandwich them with two cinnamon-spiced snickerdoodles for a soft, chewy bite that holds up beautifully in the freezer.

The Ingredients Behind That Signature Biscoff Taste

So, what makes the Biscoff flavor? It’s all about caramelized sugar, cinnamon, and a blend of warm spices. That’s what gives this biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe its distinct taste. When people ask what are the ingredients in Biscoff cream?, the answer includes crushed speculoos cookies, sugar, canola oil, soy flour, and cinnamon. It’s this rich spread that turns plain cream into a dessert that tastes like a cozy cookie straight from the oven.

And if you’re curious about what are the ingredients in Lotus Biscoff mini ice cream?, it typically includes dairy cream, cookie butter, Biscoff cookie crumbs, and a chocolate coating many of the same elements you’ll find in this biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe, just made from scratch and with that farmhouse touch.

FAQs

A Sweet Farmhouse Staple to Keep in Your Freezer

This biscoff ice cream sandwich recipe brings together the simple charm of homemade cookies, the creaminess of no-churn ice cream, and the unmistakable warmth of Biscoff cookie butter. Whether you’re serving them up on a hot July afternoon or sneaking one as a late-night treat, they never disappoint. With just a few pantry staples and a little freezer time, you’ll have a dessert that feels indulgent but is truly easy to make.

Every batch I make reminds me why I started Food and Farm to share recipes born from real life, fresh ingredients, and a love for honest flavors. From chilled desserts to hearty snacks like this chili crisp cottage cheese flatbread, I believe in creating food that’s both comforting and deeply satisfying. I hope this one finds a home in your kitchen too.